THE POSKIM SAY: If a Dayan doesnt give a reason for his Psak, that shows he doesnt have a reason or he made a mistake. Otherwise, whats he embarrassed from?! Let him show it!

THE POSKIM SAY: If a Dayan doesnt give a reason for his Psak, that shows he doesnt have a reason or he made a mistake. Otherwise, whats he embarrassed from?! Let him show it!

This logic is stated by the Nodeh B’Yehuda – (first image above) (Choshen Mishpat Siman 1 Mahdurah Tinyana); see Shu”t Rabbeinu Chaim HaKohen – (second image above) (Rappoport) (Even Ha’ezer Siman 2) (-The Baal Shem Tov held very highly of him); and the Maharik.

The Mahariaz Enzyl Siman 102 – (third image above) writes that it is not proper to make a Psak in a Get without writing the basis. He states by the famous Kliver Get story that even though the famous Gaon Reb Abish Frankfurter who was know as a holy Rav and Gaon, however, his psak that the forced Get was kosher was not accepted because he did not provide his basis on the Kliver Get.